Warthur The Black Album gets a lot of flack from Metallica fans, but personally I think it's an OK-ish album. It's not brilliant by any means; were the same tunes recorded by some band nobody had heard of for their debut album I suspect it'd have fallen into obscurity. But the fact is that it was recorded by Metallica - and what's more, given the best production job of any Metallica album to date.

Sure, the production doesn't reveal anything particularly special about the songs collected here, which are about as middle-of-the-road as metal can possibly get. But I'd very slightly prefer that to what you get on Justice For All - which is genuinely interesting, novel, and well-composed songs utterly ruined by shoddy production. It's like the difference between popcorn and gourmet food; screw up the fancy dinner and it'll taste horrible, whilst almost nobody can fail to make adequately eatable popcorn. And like average popcorn, the Black Album can be easily consumed without thinking too hard and will leave you feeling vaguely unsatisfied.

Sheavy (original review from ProgArchives)

Wow. Thats a long way down. Try not to hurt yourself on the fall. Yep, thats right the album that started the canyon between the good, the bad, and the just plain ugly. This album is still enjoyable even if it is straight ahead metal, without any of the things that made early releases interesting. The guitar work is, as always beyond good, but it is Kirk Hammett, so that is mandatory. The song writing as a lot blander than previous albums and about the only Prog moments on this album is the softer Unforgiven which just because it being sort of Proggy does not make it good at all. The other is the middle eastern tinged Wherever i May Roam, which is undeniably the best track on this record. Enter Sandman is overrated and I do not understand why this song got the attention it did because it is not that interesting and gets old after the second time of hearing, but know having heard it about 10'000 times it makes me want to plug my ears. Of Wolf And Man, The Unforgiven, and Sad But True are the other songs that i can really say i like, and the rest are just decent, if uninspired songs.

Unfortunately the bottom had not come for this band.

UMUR "Metallica" (or "The Black Album" if you will) is the 5th full-length studio album by US heavy metal/ thrash metal act Metallica. The album was released in August 1991 by Elektra Records. The band had been hugely influential and also quite commercially successful during the eighties releasing four seminal thrash metal albums in "Kill ´Em All (1983)", "Ride the Lightning (1984)", "Master of Puppets (1986)" and "... And Justice for All (1988)". All four are generally considered landmark releases in the genre. The increasingly technical playing and complex structure of the songs on especially "... And Justice for All (1988)" eventually led to the band getting tired of playing thrash metal though. They probably felt they had accomplished everything there was to accomplish in that genre and they felt the need to tone things down a bit and focus more on melody, simpler song structures and less technical playing. "The Black Album" went on to become hugely successful in terms of record sales and is one of the most important factors in the increasing acceptance of hard rock and heavy metal on mainstream radio.

So what we get on "The Black Album" are some memorable heavy metal songs that should appeal to most people in terms of heavy riffs, sing-along choruses, melodic guitar solos and varied songwriting. Six singles were released to support the album in "Enter Sandman", "Don´t Tread on Me", "The Unforgiven", "Nothing Else Matters", "Wherever I May Roam" and "Sad But True". "Don´t Tread on Me" was the least successful but the other five were hugely successful and those five songs remain classics in Metallica´s repetoire to this day. Unfortunately many of the other songs on the album come off as sub par to those five tracks. Examples could be songs like "Don't Tread on Me", "Of Wolf and Man" and "The Struggle Within". Pretty mediocre material if you ask me. None of the tracks on the album are bad though and most are enjoyable even though they are not remarkable. The thrash metal riffing style which was a big part of Metallica´s sound on the earlier releases by the band are almost completely gone from their sound on this album and there are obvious references to classic hard rock instead. "The Black Album" is still a heavy metal album first and a hard rock/ heavy rock album second though. If you are ever in doubt take a listen to the crushingly heavy main riff in "Sad But True".

The production by Bob Rock is grand and metallic sounding and suits the music well.

My personal experience with this album is rather mixed. Upon the release of "The Black Album" I was already a big fan of Metallica having been hooked in an early age by "... And Justice for All". I actually attended a concert with Metallica on Gentofte Stadium (A stadium situated in a suburb to Copenhagen, Denmark) two days before the release of the album. I´ve seen Metallica a couple of times since then (two times on the tour following the release of "The Black Album"), but that concert still stands as the best concert I´ve seen with them. Maybe because they only played "Enter Sandman" and "Of Wolf and Man" from the then, yet unreleased "Black Album". I´ve seen many people accusing Metallica of selling out but IMO the band really wanted to change their style out of artistic reasons and not because they thought they could make more money. I´m sure they didn´t exactly suffer finacially after selling as many albums as they did in the eighties. If you like their new direction is a whole other matter though and I must admit that I´m one of those that stopped listening to Metallica after this album was released. I remember listening to the album with great enthusiasm for the first couple of years after it was released but the air simply went out of the ballon somewhere along the way and I much prefer the first four albums to this one. Still it´s for the most part a high quality metal album and even though I think there are way too many filler tracks on the album to warrant a 62:40 minutes long playing time, I´d say a 3.5 - 4 star rating is warranted. Had there been more great songs like the five hits on the album I would have given a full 4. Despite my issues with the album "The Black Album" is a "classic" metal album. One of those albums you have to have heard before you leave this earth.

bonnek This is one of those albums that you either already own or can't be bothered with. Well I'll try to take up some of your precious time with another review anyway.

Many fans criticized Metallica’s knee fall to please the masses, the Black Album was said to be too commercial, not thrash enough, slick, sell-out. Those and many other outbursts of betrayed fan rage could be heard all over the place.

Well, they didn’t diminish the popularity nor the relevance of this album. With its smooth and rocking approach it brought metal to a wider public and helped making it into one of the most popular and most creative scenes of the 90's. And indeed it is an excellent starting point for discovering all things metal, it has power, aggression, shredding, epic drama and some of the most catchy tunes on any metal album. I had had some short flirts with metal in the years before, but this album started my life-long love for the genre.

But that doesn't mean everything is glorious, there's sure filler as well. Up until Don’t Thread on Me, there is no dip in the song material, with Sad But True and Wherever I May Roam being the obvious highlights. From then on the quality goes a bit up and down. Some of the songs are hardly necessary and had better been passed on to B-sides. Especially Don’t Thread on Me, Of Wolf and Man and The Struggle Within drag the album down. One of the main reasons is Ulrich's uncreative drumming again. If he would have provided more dynamic rhythms he could have given some of the more unremarkable songs a boost. The production by Bob Rock is overwhelming, but he failed in his producer’s responsibility to be critical for some of the material here.

As far as I'm concerned, this album wasn't a disappointment but a revelation. Good and relevant enough for 4 small stars. With a bit more scrutiny and a stronger album closer, this one would sit right next to their masterpieces.

poslednijat_colobar The beginning of the end

When some great musicians made their magnum opus, they've always change the direction in wrong way. Or probably wrong is not the most appropriate word here. To be more precise I would say, then the musicians take non-musical way, but the commercial. The reason could be a relief from the great works of art they did or willingness of enrichment. Somehow or other, they sold their souls to... money!!! When they did it, it's impossible to make great music any more. The perfect example of that is Metallica. After magnificent ,,,And Justice for All it is time for losing form, at the expense of earning money.

And yet the homonymous album by Metallica is not a bad album. It doesn't contain any thrash parts. There aren't weak songs, but also there aren't special, except perhaps Nothing Else Matters. It's full of mainstream and unbalanced rock songs. Direction is lost, the style, too. Obviously, the last remained trick, that save the album musically is momentum. Despite that, commercially Metallica is the most successful album by the band and one of the most successful in the history of rock music. The last one is not important for me, so 3 stars!

The Angry Scotsman The best selling album of the last 2 decades, this may be one of the most controversial as well. Not from it's reviews or sales, but this is the album where Metallica "sold out". I used to be on the boat, but then started to waffle on it. After much thought all I can say is, Metallica did indeed sell out. Was it for the money? Was it honest experimentation? I think so, we may never know for sure but I think they were dedicated to mixing it up and trying new things.

However, this album is flat out boring. There are SOME cool riffs, though most just sound generic. There are cool parts, some variation but it is not enough to hold my attention. Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven and My Friend of Misery are the only songs that I can actually listen all the way to the end without issue. Every other song is difficult to make it through, and some I can't at all.

It's a shame because they are some captivating moments. I find the lyrics and story behind The God that Failed pretty intriguing and honestly captivating, but I simply feel my head sagging and eyes closing during it. Through the Never starts well, and is pretty captivating though it gets a bit old. Nothing Else Matters is a pure ballad, no heavy. It is nice sounding but again boring overall, though I do like the ending. That is really the case with this whole album.

So, all technicality and musical talent was thrown away for even greater mass appeal. The band can do as they please, and I am a fan of experimenting, but this album is just not very good. Bland, generic, boring. Some good moments no doubt, but just too dull overall. I will say, this album has "The Unforgiven" which is one of my all time favorite Metallica songs. An amazing and powerful song that is sadly the only real high point of this album.

Metallica: 1981-1991 RIP

Two and a Half Stars

Conor Fynes 'The Black Album' - Metallica (4/10)

I like to think of the 'Black Album' as the album that killed Metallica, or at least killed their sense of musical integrity. Moving from an uncompromised metal spirit to being more or less a puppet of the almighty dollar does not go over well with me.

Now, I've never been a real fan of Metallica but I can admit that their first four albums are very noteworthy, each for different reasons. The band's debut 'Kill 'Em All' was essentially the first thrash metal album, and while it was condemned by 'metalheads' at the time (who were generally used to metal along the lines of Black Sabbath) it was destined to become the album that would define a genre. The next album 'Ride The Lightning' took the raw thrashy energy and transformed it into something even more epic. The two to follow that; 'Master Of Puppets' and '...And Justice For All' are both masterpieces that incorperated progressive elements into a metallic soundscape; something that was rarely heard of in that time. Metallica really seemed to be knocking heads with their uncompromised energy and power...

...Then the 'Black Album' came along and gave dawn to a period in the band's music that can't be considered anything short of pitiful.

It's the 'Black Album' where everything changed; where everything seemed to come crashing down for the band. There was a great musical switch with this album. Exchanging energy and creativity for accessibility and commercial nature, the band really toned down their fire and resorted to making what I can only call 'radio rock with an edge.'

The album has a few songs I really like that really do deserve praise. The song 'The Unforgiven' is among my favourites of the band, and the ballad 'Nothing Else Matters' has some great vocal and acoustic work. But most of this is basically an example of a Metallica that has been declawed by the market.

The 'Black Album' can be appreciated by your average rock listener, but for me, this album took away everything I previously appreciated about the band. I liked the band for their energy and speed. There's none of that here. Why would I give this much of a rating?

It's definately not the band's worst, and there are good songs on here. But apart from a few saving graces, there's alot of filler material that's character of a band that has sold it's soul to the record label.

AtomicCrimsonRush Metallica's The Black Album is akin to The Beatles The White Album both in style and innovation. Metallica absolutely excelled with this and shocked the metal heads who were not used to this quieter approach but when they thrash they do it at breakneck speed. Some of the riffs on this are so good they should be illegal.

When I think of this album I remember how it was raved about on the radio metal shows and how many times they played tracks from it. Indeed it was so good every track was an instant classic. Immediately the highlights spring to mind Enter Sandman, Sad but True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, Through the Never, Nothing Else Matters, My Friend of Misery - all brilliant and instantly recognizable as soon as Metallica begin playing them in concert.

The album tracks became the most played live in concert from any album, and there are some amazing versions on the orchestrated 'S & M' worth a listen.

'Nothing Else Matters' was one of the most inspired tracks in the metal world. Hetfield singing 'from the heart' and beautifully too had metal heads burning their hands with lifted up lighters every time it was played live.

Essential listening even if you hate metal. Many prog elements throughout if you look hard enough. But forget all that it's just great music and some of the best instrumentals in the annals of rock history. Of course the album was the peak of their success and the only way was down and Metallica virtually crashed to earth on later releases; Load, Reload, and the abysmal St Anger - which put them under the earth's crust. Death Magnetic brings them up to standard again but nothing was as good as this album.

The Black Album stands the test of time and will be remembered and revered for decades as the shining moment of metal. Every band has a treasure album, a 'Topographic Oceans' if you like, and for Metallica - this is it. Adore it or hate it you cannot ignore it. It was more influential and more important than any metal album in the early 90s when metal was dying. Metallica resurrected and reinvented the metal corpse with The Black Album and everyone sat up and took notice again.

Stooge This is Metallica’s first venture into rock music, but they still have the long hair and jeans. So I really don’t know what to call them, rock or metal. I think it’s the in-between state that the band is in as being the main reason I can’t fully enjoy The Black Album. I’ve had this album in my collection for almost 10 years, but honestly, there are only 3 songs out of the 12 that I can still appreciate: “Sad But True”, “The Unforgiven”, and “Of Wolf And Man”.

The heavy riff in the verse of “Sad But True” is what draws me to that song, and the chorus is rather memorable. “The Unforgiven” is without a doubt the gem of this album. It’s a powerful song with a heavy verse and slower, clean chorus, a slightly unusual structure. It’s such a good song that the band would create “sequels” of it on future albums. “Of Wolf And Man” is the heaviest song on the album, even heavier than “Sad But True”. Lars Ulrich’s drums as thunderous on this song, and like the trading off of lines between the lead and backing vocals during the chorus.

The Black Album contains a number of tracks that might keep some of the old thrash fans happy in “Holier Than Thou”, “Through The Never”, and “The Struggle Within”. These three tracks are the fastest tracks on the album and the riffing and soloing is the closest you’ll find to something from one of their previous albums. To me, these tracks just seem like they were included to please their early fan base. Whether these songs are played next to classics like “Whiplash” or “Battery” or just played alone, they sound second rate to me no matter what.

I mentioned two of the five singles already, but what about the others? Well, I have to credit “Enter Sandman” as it helped introduce Metallica to the general public (though you could say the superior “One” from the Justice album did that as well), but as a song, it becomes less impressive the more I hear it. “Nothing Else Matters” would have shocked the hell out of me if I was a teenager back in 1991. It’s a great song to learn if you’re just learning the guitar, but it’s below average as far as ballads go. I think the version they do with the orchestra on S&M is a lot more moving. “Wherever I May Roam” has one of those riffs that gets stuck in my head that I wish would leave. Some might appreciate this track’s catchiness, but I just can’t get into this song.

“Don’t Tread On Me”, “The God That Failed”, and “My Friend Of Misery” are the remaining track left to discuss. I can’t think of anything positive to say about “Don’t Tread On Me”, but I like Hetfield’s lyrics in “The God That Failed” and the bass intro on “My Friend Of Misery”. It would have been interesting to hear “My Friend Of Misery” as a more developed instrumental piece as song co-writer Jason Newsted intended.

Overall, this album is more of something a mainstream rock fan would find interesting or a Metallica fan that wishes to complete their collection. I think Metallica learn to do the rock thing better on the Load albums.

Pekka It's easy to think that Metallica's status and career changed completely after the release of the Black Album and its multi-million sales but in reality the band had been going towards the top all the time. They were already selling millions of records with their uncompromising prog thrash with pretty much no radio airplay and packing arenas around the world, so when you add to this the simpler song structures, more streamlined sound and radio play, voilà. You've got yourself some international rock superstars.

They may have sacrificed a lot of the complex structures, speed and aggression but they were still friggin' heavy as hell, best example of course being the legendarily massive riffs of Sad But True, a track unfortunately severely overplayed by rock radio and the band themselves. Their thrash past is still evident on tracks like Holier Than Thou and Through the Never, but otherwise the change in style and sound is a major one. Everybody knows Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam and Nothing Else Matters and how they broadened the idea of what Metallica music is, but my favourite tracks of the album are among the more rarely heard of. The holy trinity of this album for me is Of Wolf and Man, The God That Failed and My Friend of Misery, The God perhaps being the very favourite nowadays. A fantastic vocal performance by James (as on the whole album, up until the end of the 90s he just kept on getting better and better), one of the best Kirk solos ever and Lars showing he's at his best with this kind of slow and heavy pounding. And Jason who we get to hear for the first time delivers a massive bottom.

When reviewing this album it's difficult to balance between the way I felt when I listened to it for the first time, the 50th time and now years and years later the 500th time. When I first got my hands on it sometime in the late 90s I spent a long time listening to absolutely nothing else. And loved every listen. What it resulted in was of course that then I spent a long time unable to listen to the album at all, after which I slowly returned it to my occasional menu, a process that most of my most precious albums have gone through.

Most of the album has stood the test of time very well and sound-wise it's still one of my all time favourites from any genre. Though essential for being a big factor in introducing the masses to metal, musically it's still quite far from their finest works.

jampa17 Less music, more money. Point taken.

Well, after three wonderful prog metal albums in a row, Metallica have to choose what new to bring in the mix for the next decade. Remember that Nirvana was already a hit and everything that sounds too elaborated was banned from the media, so these guys choose to go in that direction and bring out a straight metal album, and they sell millions of albums. Now, who can blame them if they wanted to assure the University studies of their grandchildren? I won't, and you...?

Well, after this intriguing question I will describe the music of this album. If you have to say something positive about Metallica is that they know how to make you headbang even if you don't want to. Their music became short and without any complex arrangements. All that we have of the old Metallica is the great riffing that Hetfield developed as the total master of that and some brief solos here and there. The rest is pure metal and even soft metal. I don't find it bad but sure it is not my thing and the music do not entertain me as the 80's productions but at the end, this is pure metal so, just start the headbanging and you won't remember why do you hate Metallica.

To be honest, there are some songs that do deserve a chance to listen to, like Enter Sandman, Sad But True and Wherever I May Roam. More ballads (the inevitable radio hit "Nothing Else Matters" and "The Unforgiven" does ring any bell?) and some boring songs more. This is why I don't like Metallica, some songs sounds so much like fillers, but as I said above, some songs really worth the listening.

Now, in the positive aspect of this album, the vocals are better with this kind of music, more plain to fit Hetfield range. The production is a lot better and the sound improved a lot (they used the same studio than Dream Theater in the Awake album and it do has a great sound developing).

This is metal and this album has no pretentious goals. They rock, people like it, they win millions... what else you want...? a good headbanging album. I think it worth 3.75 stars... just enjoy the the good songs and skip the fillers.

Valarius The most under-overrated album of all time.

I have no idea if that is a real term, but my views on this album are simple. Any claim that this is 'the best Heavy Metal record of all time' might seem a bit far-fetched, but this is by no means a bad album. Sadly, this record probably gets more publicity for the fact that Metallica 'sold out' than for the fact that the songs here are all really great.

The whole 'selling out' thing is totally pathetic in my eyes. Even if they say something and then go back on it, all bands age, mature, and most importantly, can do whatever the hell they want to do.

Regardless of people’s opinions about the direction the band was taking here, I don't think there is any denying that the songs on here are great HEAVY METAL songs. Okay, so they aren’t as complex and progressive as previous albums, but overall the songs are all beefy, bang-your-head kick-ass Metal anthems. The nice, crisp production also adds a new depth to the music as it blasts out of your speakers.

There are one or two weaker tracks such as 'The God That Failed' and 'The Struggle Within', but they don't detract from the album at all, especially since they’re lined up next to classics such as ‘Enter Sandman’, ‘Sad But True’, ‘Nothing Else Matters’ and ‘The Unforgiven’.

Really, truly, a legendary album. ‘Nuff said.

clarke2001 Am I really first to review the Black album? Oh well. Now, the title of the review:

The album that killed the 80's.

...not entirely correct. But I'll explain it later.

'Metallica' was my first encounter with metal ('proper' metal, not the glam one) at the age of 15. Apart from the personal value, this album holds a special place in history of rock 'n' roll - it launched METALLICA on radio and opened doors for plethora of different, uncompromisable, heavy artists in the 90's. It's a second album (NIRVANA's 'Nevermind' being the first) that marked the end of an era, era of cheesy synthpop, and brought (loud!) guitars back in business. Of course, there's a palette of bands ranging from IRON MAIDEN to DIRE STRAITS that preserved the sound of rock music in the 80's - but I think you can understand my point.

'Metallica' - first off, I don't know why the album is self-titled, as it is the band's first one - , commonly known as 'The Black Album' because of its black cover, with only a name whispered almost in identical shade, (black on black!) deserves a special place in history almost as THE BEATLES' colour-counterpart.

It's also a breaking point of the band's songwriting career; you might say they took a long slope down the hill, however, it's evident they became more pop-oriented (and radio friendly) after (and with this one).

Bear in mind, it's not a sell-out, and band slightly inclined towards more 'listenable' rock format, but the album did what it did - it changed the mindset of the audience. Plus, it's far from being pop, or even bad. It's energetic and it contains a variation of different ideas, varying from rock ballads to their trash roots; the traces of progressive metal are evident only slightly, and the tracks are considerably shorter (albeit not too short), tight, packed properly to be presented to the wide world.

Of weaker tracks, I would like to pin-point forgettable 'The God That Failed', under-developed 'Whenever I May Roam' and 'The Struggle Within'. Perhaps the 'Struggle' contains decent intro (yet another adaptation of Bernstein's 'America') under the bold, chugging riff, but it's laughable, and it's certainly not THE NICE. 'Roam' contains a decent melody (and a nice sitar intro) but it seems it goes without any significant changes until the fade-out.

'Nothing Else Matters' and 'Unforgiven' (which will experience two more reincarnations in the post-black period) are, needles to say, two easiest tunes from the album ,and both of theme were major hits, as well as a roadmark of the band's new musical approach. The songs so overplayed (and overperformed - do you know ANY amateur guitar that never tried to played that open strings intro??!?), I won't be saying anything more about them.

What is left (and that's more than half an hour of material) is good metal with thrashy overtones. The quick power chord changes, unexpected jumps in dynamics of 'Master Of Puppets' and 'Justice' are gone, what's left are mostly slow to mid-paced songs with tight riffing and catchy licks, all of that dense in execution. Two of them, well-known 'Enter Sandman' and 'Sad But True' both fit in this formula, 'Sad...' emphasizing it more, while 'Sandman' being really wicked in utilizing an innocent child's voice praying among the horror spleen - very BLACK SABBATH like in its 'evilness'. The rest of the rest is worth checking, while not being the sterling material, it's far from being weak. For a general audience, the album might be an acquired taste, for a metal fan is obligatory; any rock fan should check it out and decide it for him/herself.