Server upgrade in progress, please report issue

I think we could live without symphonic death metal here. Brutal death metal I'd say is essential.

I already sent this to Chris, but I'll post my pitch for it here as well:

There's evidence that its one of death metal's bigger sub-genres. Just look at RYM's charts for each of them: brutal death has a 48 page chart. Technical death metal has 25. Death n roll has just 5. Only melodic death has a longer chart (85), and those don't count unratred and rarely rated releases. It seems strange that brutal death doesn't get a sub-genre here, but death n roll does.

Of course, quite a bit of brutal death metal can also be tagged as tech death. But there are bands out there who are considered to be just brutal death metal (for most of their albums anyway) who I think deserve to be placed correctly here, such as Suffocation, Hour of Penance, Benighted, Dying Fetus, Aborted and I'm sure many more - those were just the big names from the top of RYM's chart.


Edited by TheHeavyMetalCat - 18 Jul 2016 at 5:55am

So ? I add it ? 

Ok I do it now.

http://www.metalmusicarchives.com/subgenre/brutal-death-metal

Bosh66 wrote: Mixing and matching tagging may require a pretty extensive reworking of the site I guess and throws up its own challenges around grouping similar styled bands and accuracy. We may well end up with additional subs at some point but each one does slow down and complicate adding bands to the site. Don't underestimate how much work we still have outstanding to add tens of thousands of missing bands and also to clean up and properly site the artists we do have. Just sorting what we do have at the rate we're going is going to take a long time without spending hours isolating what is symphonic death or whatever other (valid) category we add.

Work? Then screw all subs. Just calling it metal is good enough :)
Just a thought for the utopian future site

I'm going to post this here so its got a chance of being seen this time:

I would like to propose that Traditional Heavy Metal be renamed to just Heavy Metal.

My reasoning is that having the 'traditional' in the name makes it sound like the sub-genre can only be used for genuine traditional metal bands and not modern heavy metal bands, which are essentially an evolved form of the same thing (AKA metal bands who don't fit into any other sub-genre), something which is true of most if not all metal genres.

To compare, think about how people go on about old school death or thrash metal. Yet no one bats a eye calling modern sounding death and thrash bands death and thrash still. Likewise modern heavy metal (some artists get called melodic metal) is still heavy metal.

Therefore I firmly believe the sub-genre should be renamed to reflect this.

Yeah, I've always just called it classic metal. It would look better and make more sense if the "trad" was dropped.

+1

I agree too.