Post Reply - Adam's Blog #3: On Reviewing |
Post Reply |
Message |
Topic - Adam's Blog #3: On Reviewing Posted: 21 Aug 2016 at 1:11pm By adg211288 |
^ Great contribution Travis.
The act of a counter review is tricky ground. On one hand if a review you disagree with motivates you to write your own that much you should go for it, but you've got to be subtle about it and make sure that your review can stand on its own without your reader having to go read the other review first. I'm sure many reviewers have fallen into that trap and really this also goes for referencing any other review even if you are agreeing with it: that review may not always be there after all. The reviewer may change it or pull it completely at any time.
|