WITHIN TEMPTATION The Unforgiving metal music review by Wilytank

WITHIN TEMPTATION The Unforgiving

Album · 2011 · Symphonic Metal

2/5 · 2011-08-28
Wilytank

So, I listen to Within Temptation's 'Enter' to condition myself before listening to their newest offering, 'The Unforgiving'. A lot must have happened between '97 and now, because the sound has changed a little drastically.

Now, there are times when that can be a good thing; but in this case, it isn't.

Straight from "Shot in the Dark", the impression is "This is Evanescence with Rihanna's vocals mixed with Amy Lee's. Wtf?" The music in "Faster" and "Iron" sounds like is was taken (stolen?) from an Amorphis song. In fact, there are times on this album where I wonder if Within Temptation actually did rip off Amorphis or Evanescence on this album.

The reason why I have brought up Evanescence is 1): The female vocalists, and 2): the popish appeal of the music. How Within Temptation went from a pretty interesting gothic metal band in '97 to this symphonic pop/rock now is beyond me. They've got epic sounding music in a vein NEAR Amorphis, but at least Amorphis has the progressive elements to make their music more interesting. All the guitar riffs are really simple and uninteresting. All the lyrics are pretty lame and forgettable.

Another album that won't make it on my 2011 list.

1 year ago
Permalink
Report #250876

Share this review

Review Comments

Post a public comment below | Send private message to the reviewer

Please login to post a shout

adg211288 wrote:

1 year ago

Faster sounds similar to Wicked Games, it has its own touches. It's not completely the same.They say its almost impossible to write something truly original these days anyway. The band is actually aware of the similarities between the two songs.

I agree with Xaxaar's comment. People generally seem to love or hate this album. And yes Wily, a lot has changed from Enter to The Unforgiving. A lot changed between Enter and The Dance EP to the second full-length Mother Earth. If you were to listen to all their major releases in order you'd notice the gradual shift towards The Unforgiving's sound, though this is quite different even to The Heart of Everything.

I personally consider this album a masterpiece, but maybe to use Xaxaar's words it's because I get the genre.

Xaxaar wrote:

1 year ago

Yeah, wasn't a huge fan myself...but I think it's one of those things where I just don't "get the genre." Sort of like how I look at people weird that call "In the L..L..Library Loft" (by Toby Driver) random noise when I see it as a masterpiece. I just don't think they "get the genre."

Or maybe I do and just think it's sub-par, nonetheless. >_>

Wilytank wrote:

1 year ago

oh god...

arcane-beautiful wrote:

1 year ago

faster is actually the same as HIMs Wicked Game (the Chris Issak cover)

Member Zone

Username:

Password:

Stay signed in

Not Yet Registered?

Forgotten Your Password?

Metal Sub-Genres

Artists Alpha-index

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
V.A.

MMA TOP 5 Metal ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm

Rust in Peace Thrash Metal
MEGADETH

Master of Puppets Thrash Metal
METALLICA

Crimson Death Metal
EDGE OF SANITY

Still Life Progressive Metal
OPETH

Paranoid Proto-Metal
BLACK SABBATH

More results and filters

New Metal Artists

OPENSPACE Progressive Metal
KEE MARCELLO Hard Rock
PASADENA NAPALM DIVISION Thrash Metal
INTO THE FLOOD Metalcore
FLOOD THE DESERT Progressive Metal
OPUS DÄI Hard Rock
TABÜLA Metalcore
MAD SEASON Hard Rock
MALFUNKSHUN
ONGO Hard Rock
MIKE ORLANDO Progressive Metal
ORGANIZED CHAOS Progressive Metal
ORENDA Progressive Metal
OPUS TIDE Progressive Metal
LIVIMØRKET Black Metal
SCARLET HOLLOW Hard Rock
IVAN MIHALJEVIC & SIDE EFFECTS Hard Rock
HARD TIME Hard Rock
ONYX EYES Gothic Metal
OCHRE Progressive Metal

New Metal Releases

Scion AV Label Showcase - Earache Records Thrash Metal
VEKTOR

Judas Kiss Hard Rock
KEE MARCELLO

Regnum Saturni Black Metal
FELL VOICES

Pasadena Napalm Division Thrash Metal
PASADENA NAPALM DIVISION

Reflections Metalcore
CONTRITION

More new releases

New Free Metal MP3 download/stream

VOIVOD Iron Gang
War and Pain · 1984 · Thrash Metal
NEUROSIS Given to the Rising
Given to the Rising · 2007 · Sludge/Post-metal
CONVERGE Homewrecker
Jane Doe · 2001 · Metalcore
HIGH ON FIRE Brother in the Wind
Blessed Black Wings · 2005 · Sludge/Post-metal
LEVIATHAN I Miss Watching You Die
Iuvenes/Leviathan · 2003 · Black Metal
IUVENES Necromatron
Iuvenes/Leviathan · 2003 · Black Metal
ELYSIAN BLAZE Pyramid of the Cold Son
Blood Geometry · 2010 · Black Metal
KREATOR Death to the World
Phantom Antichrist · 2012 · Thrash Metal
ABSU A Quest Into The 77th Novel
The Sun of Tiphareth · 1995 · Black Metal
GRIMMTHURS Faeton
Grimmthurs · 2013 · Death Metal